Every boat you can rent, Key West to Marathon.

Old-school full-service boatyard inside Garrison Bight. If you break something they can fix it. If you want to fish in the morning and hit a sandbar in the afternoon, they've got the right hull.

Best for: Fishing and sandbar boats, in-town Key West pickup

One boat, one job: floating tiki bar for up to 12. Captain drives, you sit under the palm-thatch roof. This is the bachelorette / birthday boat.

Best for: Group tiki cruise with a captain

The one you've seen on Instagram. Two-story pontoons with real waterslides — plus 25' single-deckers if you want less of a party. Group-friendly, sandbar-optimized, captain optional.

Best for: Double-decker sandbar days, big groups

The biggest rental fleet in Key West. When everyone else is sold out on a Saturday, Sunset usually still has a boat. Pick your hull inside their Full-Day or Half-Day listing — deck boats, pontoons, Whalers, Contenders.

Best for: Widest inventory · half or full day

Straightforward Stock Island rental yard. Five boats from a 17' skiff up to a 30' double-decker. Fair prices, no gimmicks, decent captains on the phone.

Best for: No-drama rentals from 17' to 30'

Sea Fox-focused fleet out of Hurricane Hole Marina. If you want a fishing-capable center console over an easy pontoon, this is the yard to call. Their Sea Fox Commander is their flagship.

Best for: Sea Fox center consoles, fishing-first

Skip the Key West traffic and launch straight from Cudjoe. Five hulls from an 18' Key West up to a 23' tri-hull deck boat — all the reef, all the sandbars, none of the drive-down slog.

Best for: In-Cudjoe launches from 18' to 23'

Deep bench out of Cudjoe — nine boats spanning pontoons, tritoons, deck boats and full-blown offshore center consoles. Their No Tan Lines tritoon and their WorldCat 23' are the ones we point people to.

Best for: Widest inventory up the Keys

Summerland-based rental yard leaning fishing. Seven hulls from 19' to 25' — Bennington deck boat, Cobia, Carolina Skiff, Key West CC. Solid for a family that wants a real fishing platform, not just a party boat.

Best for: Fishing-forward Summerland fleet

Marathon-based operator. Book their half or full day and pick your hull inside the FareHarbor flow — fewer decisions, one bill.

Best for: Marathon half-day or full-day

Only rental fleet out of Conch Key. Same half-day/full-day model — useful when you're staying mid-Keys and don't want the drive south.

Best for: Conch Key launches

Whaler yard. Five Boston Whalers from 22' to 27' plus two Seachasers. If you want the unsinkable classic hull — the boat every local grew up on — this is where you rent one.

Best for: Boston Whaler fleet, 22–27'

Deepest Marathon inventory — 8 boats across every category plus 1–7 day durations. Cape Horn, Parker, Sea Hunt, Mako, Proline. If you need a boat for a week straight, this is the yard.

Best for: Multi-day rentals and Marathon variety

Straightforward Marathon yard. Two Glasstream center consoles, two Hurricane deck boats that hold 10 or 12 aboard — the group boats.

Best for: Group deck boats, Marathon